The Italian (1915/1991)

Directed by Reginald Barker

IMDb
Wikipedia
Chicago Reader

The Film Registry titles The Italian (1915/1991) and Traffic in Souls (1913/2006) are both available on a DVD collection called Perils of the New Land on the Flicker Alley label.

Purchase from Amazon
Purchase from Flicker Alley

The Italian was also released on DVD on the Grapevine label.